Should I Buy a Horse With Navicular?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are an experienced rider or trainer with a clear rehab plan, access to a veterinarian familiar with navicular disease, and realistic expectations about performance limits.
• Good fit: You have a specific, low‑impact discipline in mind (e.g., leisure trail riding, therapeutic riding) where the horse’s comfort and soundness are more important than high‑speed performance.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are seeking a competitive jumper or racehorse, where navicular disease typically shortens a career and increases injury risk.
• Warning sign: You lack a trusted farrier or veterinarian experienced in managing navicular cases, making ongoing care unpredictable and costly.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Purchase price is often substantially lower than a comparable sound horse, allowing entry at a reduced upfront cost.
• If managed well, many navicular horses enjoy a comfortable, productive life in suitable disciplines, offering a rewarding partnership.

Cons

• The condition may progress despite treatment, potentially leading to chronic pain, reduced utility, or the need for euthanasia.
• Ongoing expenses for specialized shoeing, veterinary monitoring, and possible corrective procedures can add up quickly.

Decision Checklist

• Has a qualified equine veterinarian performed a thorough navicular exam, radiographs, and provided a realistic prognosis?

n

• Do you have a budget for both initial treatment (e.g., therapeutic shoeing) and long‑term maintenance?
• Is the horse’s temperament and current soundness suitable for the intended level of work?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of buying a horse already diagnosed with navicular disease, you might look for a young, sound horse and invest in preventative care, or consider leasing a horse to test suitability before committing to purchase. Adoption programs sometimes have mature horses that have recovered or are well‑managed, providing a lower‑risk entry point.

Final Recommendation

If you have the expertise, financial resources, and a low‑impact goal that matches the horse’s condition, buying a horse with navicular can be a sensible, rewarding decision. However, for most riders seeking high‑performance or without reliable veterinary support, the risks usually outweigh the cost savings. Always consult a veterinarian experienced in navicular disease before finalizing any purchase.