Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: You have already established a solid rapport with Astarion, have completed his personal quest lines, and the book is not required for any critical main‑story objective.
- Good fit: You are pursuing a romance or deeper friendship with Astarion and want to trigger the unique “shared secret” dialogue that only appears after gifting the book.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: The book is a key item for an unsolved side quest that could provide valuable loot, lore, or a crucial plot resolution.
- Warning sign: You have not yet earned Astarion’s trust; gifting a valuable item prematurely may cause suspicion or negative reactions from other companions.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Strengthens your relationship with Astarion, potentially unlocking exclusive dialogue, quests, or romance content.
- Shows role‑playing consistency if your character’s backstory or personality aligns with generosity toward vampires or morally ambiguous allies.
Cons
- You lose a potentially useful inventory item that might be needed for a separate quest, puzzle, or trade.
- Other companions may view the gift as favoritism, leading to tension or reduced cooperation in group dynamics.
Decision Checklist
- Is the book required for any active quest or puzzle you have not yet solved?
- Do you already have a strong, trust‑based relationship with Astarion, or is the gift intended to build that trust?
- Will gifting the book negatively affect the morale or loyalty of other party members?
Alternatives to Consider
If you are unsure, you can keep the book in your inventory until you have clarified its purpose, trade it to a merchant for gold, or give it to another companion who may benefit more from the item. Some players also choose to place the book in a safe storage chest and revisit the decision after completing related side quests.
Final Recommendation
Give the book to Astarion only if you have confirmed that it is not essential for any unfinished quest and you are actively seeking to deepen his relationship. Otherwise, retain the book or explore alternative uses to avoid missing out on important story content. For high‑stakes choices—such as sacrificing a unique quest item—consult community guides or seasoned players for additional perspective.
FAQ
Should I Give The Book To Astarion?
If the book is not needed for any pending quest and you want to strengthen Astarion's relationship, gifting it is a sensible choice. Otherwise, keep it safe until you verify its importance.
What should I consider before I Give The Book To Astarion?
Check if the book is a required quest item, assess your current standing with Astarion and other companions, and think about alternative uses such as selling or storing the book.
Leave a Reply