Should I Kill Dung Eater?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are focused on maximizing loot and completing every optional boss, and you don’t mind the darker narrative implications of eliminating a cursed NPC.
• Good fit: You have already progressed far enough in the Dung Eater quest that killing him will unlock the final secret weapon (the Bloody Helice) and end that story arc cleanly.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You prefer a role‑playing approach that spares NPCs, or you want to keep the Dung Eater alive for future dialogue and possible quest variations.
• Warning sign: You are still early in the game and lack the combat power to defeat the Dung Eater without heavily taxing your resources, which could hinder overall progression.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• You obtain unique rewards such as the Dung Eater’s Remembrance, which can be exchanged for powerful gear or a powerful Ash of War.
• Killing him resolves a morally ambiguous storyline, giving a sense of closure and freeing you from future encounters that could trigger unwanted consequences.

Cons

• The fight is challenging; failure can waste Runes and consumables, especially if you attempt it before you are adequately prepared.
• Eliminating the Dung Eater removes optional dialogue and lore content that may enrich the world and affect other NPCs’ reactions.

Decision Checklist

• Do I have the appropriate level, gear, and upgrade status to survive the Dung Eater’s attacks without excessive risk?
• Am I interested in the unique items and story closure that come from his defeat, or do I value the ongoing narrative possibilities?
• Is there a risk of losing access to any future quest branches or NPC interactions if I kill him now?

Alternatives to Consider

If you are uncertain, you can postpone the encounter until you feel stronger, or you can completely avoid the Dung Eater by taking alternative paths in the game world. Some players also choose to spare him by leaving the area and returning later, allowing the quest to evolve based on in‑game events rather than a final kill.

Final Recommendation

For players who enjoy thorough exploration, want the exclusive loot, and are comfortable with a tougher boss, killing Dung Eater is a rewarding choice. If you prefer a more compassionate playthrough, want to preserve optional dialogue, or are still building combat strength, consider delaying or avoiding the kill until you can better assess the trade‑offs. As always, weigh your personal objectives and, for high‑stakes decisions that affect your overall game experience, consult community guides or experienced players for additional insight.