Should I Play RDR before RDR2?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You enjoy narrative continuity and want to experience John Marston’s story before seeing his legacy in RDR2, which deepens emotional impact.
• Good fit: You have limited gaming time and prefer to finish a shorter, older title first, using it as a low‑commitment preview before committing to the longer RDR2.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You value modern game mechanics and smooth controls; the original RDR’s dated engine may frustrate you and diminish enjoyment of the sequel.
• Warning sign: You are unfamiliar with the story and risk spoilers, as playing the sequel first can reveal plot twists that the original intended to set up.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Provides narrative context that makes RDR2’s character arcs and world‑building richer.
• Offers a shorter, lower‑cost way to sample Rockstar’s Western storytelling before buying the larger, more expensive sequel.

Cons

• The original game’s graphics, UI, and combat feel dated, which can feel out of step with today’s standards.
• Time spent on the first game may be perceived as redundant if you plan to replay story elements in RDR2’s flashbacks.

Decision Checklist

• Do I prioritize story continuity over modern gameplay experience?
• Am I comfortable investing 15‑20 hours in an older title before playing a 60‑hour sequel?
• Will playing the original potentially spoil key twists that RDR2 builds on, and am I okay with that?

Alternatives to Consider

If you want the story without revisiting older mechanics, you can start directly with RDR2 and rely on its built‑in flashback sequences that summarize key events from the first game. Another option is to watch a concise plot synopsis or gameplay review of RDR to gauge interest before purchasing.

Final Recommendation

For players who value narrative depth and have time to explore a classic title, playing Red Dead Redemption before Red Dead Redemption 2 is worthwhile. If modern gameplay, time efficiency, or avoiding potential spoilers are higher priorities, start with RDR2 and use summaries or videos to fill gaps. As always, weigh your own preferences and consult community forums if you need additional perspective.