Should I Sell Opal And Amber Botw?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You have an excess of Opal and Amber after completing most side quests, and you need rupees quickly to purchase a key weapon or armor upgrade.
• Good fit: You are focusing on a playthrough where combat power is prioritized over completing every gem-related puzzle, making the gems more valuable as currency than as collectibles.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are early in the game and still have several shrines or quests that require Opal or Amber to unlock, so selling them could stall progress.
• Warning sign: You are aiming for 100% completion or want to keep all rare items for collection purposes; selling reduces the chance of achieving that goal.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Selling provides a quick influx of rupees, enabling faster upgrades or purchases without grinding.
• Reduces inventory clutter, making it easier to manage limited inventory slots while exploring.

Cons

• Opal and Amber are finite resources; once sold, you cannot retrieve them without re‑gathering, which can be time‑consuming.
• Future puzzles, shrine upgrades, or side‑quest rewards may depend on having these gems, potentially forcing you to backtrack.

Decision Checklist

• Do I have enough alternative sources of rupees for my immediate needs?
• Are there any upcoming quests or shrines that specifically require Opal or Amber?
• Will selling these gems compromise my long‑term goals such as 100% completion or collection milestones?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of selling, you could trade Opal and Amber for items that have resale value later, store them in your inventory for use in later puzzles, or deposit them in a bank chest (if using a mod that adds storage) to keep them safe while freeing up immediate space.

Final Recommendation

If you are mid‑ to late‑game with surplus gems and a clear need for rupees, selling Opal and Amber can be a pragmatic choice. However, if you are early in the adventure or pursuing full completion, consider holding onto them or using them for quest requirements. In any high‑stakes planning, especially when aiming for 100% completion, consult dedicated game guides or community resources for optimal resource management.