Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: In a league where quarterbacks score a disproportionate share of points (e.g., PPR leagues with a high passing‑yard bonus or leagues that award bonuses for 300‑yard games), securing two reliable starters can give you a competitive edge.
- Good fit: When the draft pool contains a clear drop‑off after the top three or four quarterbacks, and you have early picks that allow you to grab two quality options without sacrificing core skill positions.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: In standard leagues with shallow quarterback scoring or where a single quarterback can outscore most position groups, using two early picks on QBs may leave you short at RB, WR, or TE.
- Warning sign: If your league has a limited roster size (e.g., 12‑team with 1‑QB starter slots), carrying two QBs can force you to bench one for the entire season, reducing overall roster efficiency.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Provides insurance against injury, bye weeks, or under‑performance of a single quarterback.
- Creates strategic flexibility for weekly match‑ups, allowing you to play the quarterback with the most favorable opponent.
Cons
- Consumes valuable draft capital that could be used to strengthen depth at running back, wide receiver, or tight end.
- May lead to a weaker bench overall, especially in leagues where only one quarterback starts each week.
Decision Checklist
- Do the scoring settings in my league reward quarterbacks more than other positions?
- Do I have early enough picks to secure two quality quarterbacks without sacrificing key skill positions?
- Is my roster size and starting‑lineup configuration conducive to carrying two quarterbacks safely?
Alternatives to Consider
Instead of drafting two quarterbacks, you might target a high‑upside quarterback later in the draft and pair them with a reliable starter taken early. Another option is to draft a single top‑tier QB and use the extra early pick for a top running back or wide receiver, then monitor the waiver wire for a streaming quarterback during bye weeks.
Final Recommendation
If your league’s scoring favors quarterbacks and you have early picks that let you secure two solid starters without compromising depth at other positions, drafting two QBs can be a prudent move. In standard formats or tighter rosters, it’s usually safer to prioritize skill positions and consider a single QB strategy, supplementing with waiver‑wire options later. Always review your league’s specific rules and, for high‑stakes leagues, discuss strategies with trusted advisors or seasoned teammates.
FAQ
Should I Draft 2 Qbs?
It depends on your league’s scoring, roster limits, and where you pick in the draft. In QB‑heavy formats with early picks, two QBs can be advantageous; otherwise, focusing on other positions may yield a stronger overall roster.

Leave a Reply