Should I Give The Sword Of Jyggalag Or Amber?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are deep into the main quest line where Jyggalag explicitly requests the sword to restore order. Handing it over fulfills a critical objective, unlocks the quest reward, and advances the storyline.
• Good fit: Amber is a companion whose personal quest requires a legendary weapon to defeat a unique enemy. Giving the sword to Amber strengthens her combat ability, improves her loyalty, and may grant you exclusive companion rewards.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are unsure about the long‑term narrative consequences of empowering Jyggalag; the decision could shift the game world’s balance, leading to unforeseen challenges later.
• Warning sign: Amber’s quest is optional and you have limited inventory space. Giving away the sword may leave you without a high‑damage weapon for other content.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Giving the sword to Jyggalag may unlock a powerful order‑aligned set and story resolution that is otherwise inaccessible.
• Gifting the sword to Amber can boost her effectiveness, deepen the companion bond, and provide unique dialogue and reward options.

Cons

• Handing the sword to Jyggalag might weaken your own combat capability if you rely on it for high‑level encounters.
• Giving the sword to Amber could prevent you from using it in solo content or selling it for valuable gold before the companion quest concludes.

Decision Checklist

• Is completing Jyggalag’s quest a priority for your current playthrough?
• Do you need a strong companion for upcoming challenging content?
• Will you have an alternative source of high‑damage weapons if you give the sword away?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of giving the sword away, you could temporarily store it in a safe (e.g., a house chest) and revisit the decision later, sell it for gold to fund other gear upgrades, or trade it with a neutral merchant for a different item that fits both quest lines.

Final Recommendation

If your primary goal is story completion and you have a reliable backup weapon, giving the Sword of Jyggalag to Jyggalag is a sensible choice. If your focus is companion development and you value Amber’s synergy, gifting the sword to her offers meaningful role‑playing benefits. Weigh inventory space, future combat needs, and the importance of each quest line before deciding, and consult community forums or official guides for any high‑stakes implications.