Should I Kill Fiona?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are playing a high‑risk, anti‑hero build focused on lethal solutions and want a dramatic payoff that reinforces your character’s ruthless reputation. In that context, eliminating Fiona can provide a sense of narrative consistency and may unlock specific dialogue or loot tied to the act.
• Good fit: Your role‑playing objectives include exploring the darkest possible outcomes of the game’s moral system, and you have already completed major story arcs where Fiona’s survival no longer influences critical plot threads. Here, the decision can serve as a final statement about your character’s philosophy.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are still early in the main storyline and Fiona is tied to upcoming missions that provide essential gear, experience, or story insight. Killing her now could lock you out of content that enriches the overall experience.
• Warning sign: Your playstyle values character relationships and you aim for a “good” or “balanced” ending. Removing Fiona will close off several supportive dialogue options and may affect the ending variants that depend on her survival.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Provides immediate narrative closure and a clear, decisive action that matches a hardcore, lethal role‑play.
• May grant exclusive loot, experience, or reputation bonuses tied to the specific combat encounter, rewarding skillful execution.

Cons

• Locks you out of future missions, side‑quests, and relationship bonuses that rely on Fiona being alive, potentially reducing overall game completion percentage.
• Can alter the tone of the story toward a darker ending, which may not align with the player’s desired emotional payoff or may limit access to certain ending scenes.

Decision Checklist

• Does your character concept embrace a lethal, uncompromising approach, and will killing Fiona reinforce that vision?
• Are there any pending quests, gear rewards, or narrative branches that specifically require Fiona’s survival?
• Have you considered how this choice will affect the game’s multiple endings and your overall satisfaction with the story?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of killing Fiona outright, you could opt for non‑lethal incapacitation, which keeps her alive for future interactions while still asserting dominance. Another alternative is to delay the decision until after completing the missions she’s involved in, allowing you to weigh the full set of consequences. If you seek a darker narrative but don’t want to lose content, consider role‑playing a betrayal that leads to exile rather than death, which can unlock unique dialogue without permanently removing her from the world.

Final Recommendation

If your role‑playing goals center on a ruthless, high‑stakes experience and you have already finished the content that depends on Fiona, killing her can be a satisfying, story‑consistent choice. However, for most players who value the full breadth of Cyberpunk 2077’s narrative, keeping Fiona alive preserves optional quests, relationship depth, and ending variety. We recommend evaluating the checklist above, completing any Fiona‑related missions first, and only proceeding with the kill if it aligns with your character’s core philosophy. For any high‑stakes decision that may affect your overall game progress, consider backing up your save file beforehand.