Should I Kill Gortash Or Orin First?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: If your party excels at handling strong single enemies and you want to remove the main quest antagonist early, killing Gortash first can streamline the narrative and prevent his later interference.
• Good fit: If Orin’s abilities or location create a tactical bottleneck for your current objectives—such as blocking access to a key area—eliminating him first may open up safe passage and reduce immediate danger.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: If your characters are low on resources (health, spells, consumables) and the fight with Gortash is known to be especially challenging, attempting his removal first could jeopardize the entire party.
• Warning sign: When you are pursuing optional storylines or side quests tied to Orin, killing him prematurely may lock out valuable content, dialogue, or equipment.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Eliminating Gortash early can prevent a powerful enemy from resurfacing later, reducing future combat intensity.
• Taking out Orin first may grant immediate access to areas, loot, or quests that would otherwise be blocked.

Cons

• Gortash is typically a high‑level encounter; failing could result in severe party attrition or forced retreat.
• Orin might provide crucial information, items, or narrative hooks that enrich the overall experience; killing him too soon can diminish story depth.

Decision Checklist

• Do I have sufficient health, spell slots, and consumables to survive Gortash’s toughest abilities?
• Will removing Orin now close off any side quests or character arcs I care about?
• Which opponent’s defeat aligns better with my immediate strategic goals (e.g., opening a path vs. reducing a future threat)?

Alternatives to Consider

You could try a hybrid approach: weaken Gortash through sabotage, crowd‑control, or environmental aids before tackling Orin, or vice‑versa. Another option is to avoid both confrontations temporarily by pursuing alternative quest lines that grant stronger gear or allies, then return when better prepared.

Final Recommendation

Assess your party’s current strength and narrative priorities. If you are well‑equipped and prefer to clear the main antagonist early, targeting Gortash first is sensible. If you need immediate access or want to preserve optional content, eliminate Orin first. In either case, pause to verify resources and consider delaying the fight until you’ve secured better gear or allies. For high‑stakes decisions, especially in a competitive multiplayer setting, consult experienced players or walkthroughs for detailed tactics.