Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: Your party is pursuing a questline that directly conflicts with Redhammer’s objectives, and eliminating him clears a path to critical story milestones without requiring complex diplomacy.
- Good fit: You are playing a character with a strict alignment or role‑play motive (e.g., a lawful good paladin who cannot tolerate Redhammer’s betrayal) and the narrative rewards align with a decisive, lethal outcome.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: Redhammer is tied to a side quest that grants unique items, experience, or lore, and killing him would permanently lock that content for your current playthrough.
- Warning sign: Your party’s composition or moral code emphasizes non‑lethal solutions, and taking Redhammer’s life could cause internal conflict, reputation penalties, or alignment drift.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Immediate removal of a hostile NPC can simplify combat encounters and reduce future ambushes.
- Storywise, a decisive kill can unlock alternate endings, achievement trophies, or role‑play satisfaction for players who enjoy swift justice.
Cons
- Eliminating Redhammer may foreclose optional dialogue, branching quests, and unique loot that are only accessible through a negotiated outcome.
- Choosing violence can affect your character’s alignment, reputation with factions, and may trigger retaliation from allies of Redhammer later in the game.
Decision Checklist
- Does Redhammer’s death block any quests or rewards you still want to experience?
- Will killing him align with your party’s role‑play goals and alignment preferences?
- Have you explored non‑lethal alternatives (e.g., intimidation, persuasion, or linking his fate to another NPC) to gauge potential outcomes?
Alternatives to Consider
Instead of a straight kill, you can attempt to incapacitate Redhammer, bargain for his surrender, or use crowd‑control spells that neutralize him temporarily. These approaches preserve story branches while still mitigating his threat. If your party has strong diplomatic skills, you might even turn Redhammer into an ally for a limited time, gaining access to his unique abilities without the finality of death.
Final Recommendation
If your primary goal is narrative efficiency, alignment consistency, or unlocking a specific lethal ending, killing Redhammer can be a valid choice. However, if you value comprehensive world exploration, collectible loot, and maintaining moral flexibility, consider non‑lethal or diplomatic routes first. As with any major decision in a role‑playing game, reflect on how the outcome fits your overall playstyle, and remember that you can always reload a previous save if the consequences feel unsatisfactory.
FAQ
Should I Kill Redhammer?
Killing Redhammer makes sense if you need to remove a direct threat to your main objectives or align with a strict lawful role‑play, but it also blocks side‑quest content and can affect alignment. Weigh your narrative priorities and explore non‑lethal options first.

Leave a Reply