Should I Draft Mark Andrews?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are in a PPR (points per reception) league and have an early 2nd‑round pick, allowing you to secure a top‑tier tight end without sacrificing a cornerstone RB or WR.
• Good fit: Your roster construction values a reliable red‑zone target; Andrews consistently scores touchdowns and offers a high floor even when his yardage fluctuates.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are drafting in a late‑round heavy league where tight ends rarely get more than 5‑10 points; spending an early pick on Andrews may limit depth at RB/WR.
• Warning sign: You have concerns about his health history—past ankle injuries and a recent hamstring issue—making you uneasy about relying on him for a large portion of your weekly points.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• High target share in a pass‑heavy offense provides a stable weekly floor and strong upside in big‑play situations.
• Consistent red‑zone usage translates to a reliable touchdown upside, especially valuable in standard scoring formats.

Cons

• Injury risk: Andrews has missed time in previous seasons, and tight ends generally lack depth, magnifying the impact of missed games.
• Draft cost: Securing him often requires a 2nd‑round pick, which could be used on a high‑volume WR or RB in many drafts.

Decision Checklist

• Do I have a draft slot early enough (2nd‑round or earlier) to get Andrews without overpaying for a position you could fill later?
• Is my league scoring format (PPR, TD‑heavy, or standard) conducive to tight‑end value?
• Do I have sufficient depth at RB/WR to absorb the opportunity cost of drafting a tight end early?

Alternatives to Consider

If the risk‑reward balance feels off, consider targeting a mid‑tier tight end like Dallas Goedert or Mike Gesicki in the 3rd‑4th rounds. In deeper leagues, streaming tight ends based on matchups can free up early picks for elite skill positions. Another path is to wait for a later round and select a high‑upside rookie or a less‑proven veteran who could break out, saving early capital for RB/WR depth.

Final Recommendation

Mark Andrews is a strong candidate when you can secure him without compromising core RB/WR depth and when your league rewards receptions and touchdowns. Evaluate your draft position, scoring settings, and roster flexibility before committing. If doubts remain—especially around injury risk or draft cost—explore comparable tight ends or a streaming approach, and always consider consulting fantasy football analysts for the latest season outlook.